Why do you think Jesus was divine?
I'm really asking. I'd like to hear responses. It's the question at the very heart of Christianity: Jesus, as the embodiment of God on earth, swept clean the tablets and singlehandedly carved out a new faith. If he
was divine, then Christianity is the true faith. If Jesus was only human, then Christianity is a (mostly) terrific set of ideals based on some really creative historical documentation.
(This gets a bit complicated, so you might want to pass if you're feeling twitchy today.)
Firstly, I question the logic surrounding Jesus
as God. If Jesus was genuinely God on earth, then he was all-loving, all-knowing, infinite. He'd have been a miracle-worker; the sweetest, loveliest fellow around. And he'd have known his own future, from birth to painful death. In fact, God's infinite nature is supposed to render past and future meaningless, because he sees every moment now.
Without going into the implications of experiencing the same moment for all eternity (because I'm fixating a little on the driving of the nails), it is logically inconceivable that Jesus could have the properties of an infinite being, bound within a human (therefore limited) body.
Because apparently, Jesus wasn't just divine. He had two natures: he
was God, but possessed a complete human identity also. As a human, he would be limited by his body, by the physical laws, by mortality. And scripture appears to show elements of both natures: he aged, he bled, he hungered, he was subject to emotion. Yet his biographies are peppered with all these little miracles. The walking-on-water incident, for one. That part was God, I guess.
But far more sordid was the ressurrection. Jesus was tortured to death in a barbaric, humiliating fashion and, like a human, he suffered and died. And then, like someone decidedly
not human, he returned.
But note: he still bore the physical scars of his torture. His human body had endured those days of starvation and blood loss, and it was that human body - not just the divine entity within it - that had been ressurrected. And according to the Christian faith, Jesus will return again. Now, I'm not going to make any Zombie Jesus jokes. But in all seriousness,
what will return again? If the Christ is a dual being, both human and God, then a return by
God only could not be called the second coming of Jesus. But a return by the
complete entity of the Christ would imply the presence of the human Jesus. The limited, physical, extremely dead Jesus. (Or would any human do? Because that doesn't seem right, somehow.)
...so, Jesus died on the cross for our sins. Here's the background of this theory: In BC times, the Jews had a tradition of animal sacrifice. To absolve their sins, they would take a healthy animal (this was specified: it had to be one of value, not a lame token) and slaughter it in the name of God.
The death of Jesus was, then, a deliberate act by God to pardon the sins of humanity. It represented not martyrdom, but human sacrifice. And that means, regardless of his divine and infinite nature, Jesus died as a man.
Why make death the price of absolution? And why - if God is so insistent on humanity having free will - would he choreograph the entirety of Jesus's life and death?
The story of Jesus's death means nothing to me. I'm not into torture porn, and in any case I don't think anyone believes it is death that defines us. It is life, and how we live it, the choices we make, the things we strive for and sometimes achieve. And the story of Jesus's life is worth everything. I prefer to see it as a historical document, with supernatural elements added by its propagandist authors. Though the specifics of Bible morality are flawed, Jesus has provided us with a philosophy for
finding our own morality. He was not prescriptive - "thou shalt" and the like - but demonstrated goodness by performing it and allowing us to recognise it.
My view is this.
Jesus being God makes Jesus a cipher: nothing but the shadow-flesh of something that cannot truly be contained.
Jesus being human makes Jesus a great man.
_____
So my question stands. If you are Christian, I beg for your considered response. Why do you believe Jesus was divine?